Forgeries and Facsimiles seen on Online Auction Sites, etc

[Ross Ewington]

PLEASE POST ANY SUITABLE ITEMS TO THIS TOPIC


This item was offered on eBay during June 2009. It is most likely to have been produced
as a facsimile rather than a forgery as the size of the margins aren't going to fool anybody.
Can anyone suggest a name as a possible producer of this stamp and postmark?

[Ross Ewington]

This poor forgery of a 4d Courier was offered on eBay in early 2009. Despite several appeals
to the vendor to stop proclaiming it as a top example of a genuine stamp and "come clean",
the item remained as originally described until sold (for about US$90 or so if I remember correctly)
Although the image (from the eBay listing) is poor, can anyone suggest a name for the forger?

[Revenuer]

Spot the Forgery!

Rubbish.jpg (36.3 KiB) Viewed 727402 times

On eBay September 2009

Dave

[Ross Ewington]

1d courier forgery.jpg (41.06 KiB) Viewed 727350 times

here's another tough one to spot !!

[Ross Ewington]

These Couriers were offered as forgeries by Status International in their January 28th 2010 Public Auction (Sale #263 - Lot 1371)

[attachment=0]couriers forgeries.jpg[/attachment]
Catalog Description: 1853 QV Courier 1d blue & 4d orange, both being early forgeries with engraved designs. SG ex1/12 would cat £1400 as genuine.
Quite scarce & interesting reference items. (2) ESTIMATE: A$200

[Ross Ewington]

This forgery of a 4d Courier was offered for sale as genuine
on eBay during March 2010

4d courier fake 2.jpg (45.7 KiB) Viewed 727298 times

[Ross Ewington]

Noting that a Sperati reproduction of the £1 QV Key Type is being offered at auction by Prestige Philately
on April 10th and having a copy of the very scarce "Sperati" books published by the BPA in 1955 to hand,
I thought it would be a good time to post an image of the stamp on offer and the relevant text and plate from the book.

[attachment=2]sperati 2.jpg[/attachment]
[attachment=1]sperati 1.jpg[/attachment]
[attachment=0]sperati 3.jpg[/attachment]


The auction listing can be viewed at : http://www.prestigephilately.com/cats.p ... ionnum=155
See Lot 223.

[Ross Ewington]

A forgery this bad shouldn't fool anyone but a hopeful eBay vendor had still
used it to "up" the total catalog value of an otherwise lacklustre lot.

The forged obliterator postmark is a useful reference.

[attachment=0]4d chalon forgery.jpg[/attachment]

[Ross Ewington]

this 3d St George & Dragon was offered on eBay during November 2010 - item 300488485910

it has a poorly cleaned fiscal cancel (that anyone interested should have seen as the vendor
provided an excellent large image for inspection) and what I believe to be a forged 'TASMANIA' barred
obliterator ...am I right here (i.e. that it's a forged cancellation)??
[attachment=0]3d st george faked cancel.jpg[/attachment]

[Ross Ewington]

courier forgery.jpg (32.36 KiB) Viewed 726991 times

Offered on eBay as a SUPERB forgery during April 2011
...at least the vendor got the 'forgery' bit right in the description!

[Revenuer]

397_001.jpg (15.89 KiB) Viewed 726516 times

338_001.jpg (19.28 KiB) Viewed 726516 times

[Ross Ewington]

just seen on eBay (November 4th 2011) ...

2d chalon forgery.jpg (59.67 KiB) Viewed 726419 times

I can't recall having seen this particular forgery before - does anyone know who produced it?

[David McNamee]

Mavis Pope illustrates this 2d. Says engraved and heavily inked. Created by unknown forger. I have seen fake Courier 4d also with that cancel type.

[Ross Ewington]

Listed on eBay as item 110775726882 - described correctly by the vendor.

5sh sideface forgery.jpg (72.05 KiB) Viewed 726403 times

[Ross Ewington]

Seen offered on eBay (Item 300636474049 - December 2011)

2d chalon forgery 2.jpg (15.52 KiB) Viewed 726374 times

[Ross Ewington]

Seen offered on eBay as a postally used postal fiscal, early January 2012 - item 260925723421

the stamp is genuine but .....

[attachment=0]cleaned St George.jpg[/attachment]

....nuff sed!

[Ross Ewington]

Yet to be seen on an Online Auction site but they will be later in the year.

Forgeries attributed to Jeffryes of the 1d and 4d Couriers....

w531.jpg (77.75 KiB) Viewed 726254 times

[eelyfree]

hi
Here is a lithographed forgery of the 1/- chalon. Its not actually been seen on an auction site although I am selling some australian states in on-line auctions. It is easily spotted the earrings are very poorly depicted. I have only ever seen this one copy although I have seen several forgeries of the Courrier issues. I did wonder if it could be a postal forgery as its not a hughely valuble stamp and not good enough to fool collectors. does any one know more about this forgery ?
Thanks for looking

forg.jpg (16.73 KiB) Viewed 726250 times

[Ross Ewington]

I think this falls into the 'facsimile' (poor) category and as you mention, not good enough to fool collectors.

An interesting feature is the postmark which is very similar to the one applied to the forgery/facsimile of the 2d Chalon listed above...
[attachment=1]forged postmark 1.jpg[/attachment]
[attachment=0]forged postmark 2.jpg[/attachment]http://tps.org.au/bb/posting.php?mode=r ... =12#pr3138

Thanks for your first post 'eelyfree' - I hope that you find the TPS BB a useful and friendly place for seeking and sharing information about Tasmanian stamps and postal history.

[Ross Ewington]

Just seen on eBay - another example of the forged 2d QV Chalon with 'evil eye'!

2d chalon forgery 4.jpg (73.33 KiB) Viewed 725778 times

2d chalon forgery 3.jpg (105.28 KiB) Viewed 725778 times

[Hobbit123]

And now for something completely different. Seen several times on EBay, a replica set of the Tablet issue to £1. Sold as a replica, and stated to have REPLICA on the back of each stamp.

Replica Tablets.JPG (429.06 KiB) Viewed 725823 times

Makes a change from all those Chalons and Couriers.

[Ross Ewington]

Seen on eBay - March 10th 2013

Fortunately, the vendor has described the item correctly as being a forgery.

1sh chalon forgery.jpg (224.68 KiB) Viewed 725814 times

Interesting to note that the forger must have produced a die with at least two units (see frame
line of an adjoining 'stamp' on top margin).

[Ross Ewington]

just noted this item being offered on eBay, a very poor forgery of a 2d Chalon

dodgy chalon.JPG (42.59 KiB) Viewed 725805 times

vendor obviously a professional as he states (after the catalog number and assigned
c.v.), "This stamp could be a forgery".

[Hobbit123]

Here is a trio of forgeries that I bought from a dealer (as forgeries).

Forgeries.jpg (141.54 KiB) Viewed 725798 times

The 4d is fair, but obvious, the other two are clearly forged. I note the forged postmark (South Doo??). Has anyone else sen this cancelling a forgery?

[Ross Ewington]

seen offered on eBay - September 2013

dodgy 6d Tablet Specimen.jpg (121.82 KiB) Viewed 725660 times